A couple of days ago John calls me up and tells me I am not going to believe what he just tried at lunch. He was so excited to tell me he tried the Carls Jr Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwiches. We had seen the signs for the ice cream sandwiches a few weeks ago and thought they looked interesting/odd and were not sure if they would be good or not. I must admit that I am not a Pop Tart fan so I knew they would not be something I would try. John was so excited about them that he said we had to make a Copy Cat Carls Jr Pop-Tart Ice Cream Sandwich for the blog.
Copy Cat Carls Jr Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich
I told him that we could definitely make a Copy Cat Carls Jr Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich for the blog whenever he wanted. Well here we are and I have to say I am not even sure you can call this a recipe.
This may be the easiest Copy Cat Recipe we have ever posted. In fact, I am positive this is the easiest Copy Cat Recipe we have ever posted and we have done a ton of them.
There are 2 ingredients and 3 steps needed to make this Copy Cat Carls Jr Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich.
The Copy Cat Carls Jr Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich is made with strawberry Pop Tarts and Vanilla Ice Cream. Yep that is it! 2 whole ingredients.
You can make these with any flavor Pop Tart that you love! You can get super creative and change up the ice cream flavors for even more fun.
Step 1....Cut the Pop Tart in half
Step 2. Add a scoop of Vanilla ice cream to the top of one of the Pop Tart pieces
Step 3. Place the other piece on top and enjoy.
John said that these Ice Cream Sandwich remind him of a piece of cake. Let us know what you think of them. I think they are pretty funny and not what I would have ever thought we would be writing a post about.
You can check out Amazon to see all of the epic flavors of Pop Tarts available right now.
Great Copycat Recipes
Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich
- 1 Pop Tart Any Flavor
- ½ cup ice cream
- Cut Pop-Tart in half, Scoop ice cream and squish between the 2 pop-tart pieces.
Recipe originally shared on August 29, 2013. Updated December 2020